← All articles

Why ChatGPT recommends you but Google doesn't

6 min read
Two overlapping circles labelled ChatGPT and Google AI Mode; the overlap is marked 3.5% of cited pages in common. Both mostly cite Slovak sites; ChatGPT also Reddit and LinkedIn, Google AI Mode also LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram

You ask ChatGPT for companies in your field and yours is in the answer. You ask Google, in AI Mode or in Gemini, and you're not there. That is usually not a fault on your website: ChatGPT and Google's AI answers read different pages, so one can know you while the other never comes across you. In the 10,775 answers we recorded, the pages they cite barely overlap.

What we see in our data

citeme.eu regularly asks AI chatbots the questions a customer might ask and stores each answer together with the pages the chatbot cited. From June 20, 2026 to November 13, 2026 we collected 10,775 answers with cited pages to Slovak questions: 4,295 from ChatGPT, 4,192 from Google AI Mode and 2,288 from Gemini.

For the same question on the same day, ChatGPT and Google AI Mode share only 3.5% of the pages they cite, ChatGPT and Gemini 4.7%. Gemini and Google AI Mode are the closest pair, and even they share only 11.2%.

CHART 01

How many cited pages two chatbots have in common for the same question, and how many one chatbot keeps between two checks

ChatGPT
Gemini
Google AI Mode
ChatGPT
21.8%same chatbot
4.7%shared pages
3.5%shared pages
Gemini
4.7%shared pages
29.3%same chatbot
11.2%shared pages
Google AI Mode
3.5%shared pages
11.2%shared pages
42.1%same chatbot

Off the diagonal: two chatbots, the same question, the same day. On the diagonal: the same chatbot, two consecutive checks of the same question. 100% would mean exactly the same pages.

citeme.eu, 10,775 ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Mode answers to Slovak questions, 20 June – 13 November 2026. Pairs of answers compared: 3,274 (ChatGPT and AI Mode), 1,885 (ChatGPT and Gemini), 1,659 (Gemini and AI Mode); consecutive checks: 3,785 (ChatGPT), 1,927 (Gemini), 3,769 (AI Mode).

The diagonal of the chart shows something else: even the same chatbot does not stick to its sources. Between two consecutive checks of the same question, ChatGPT keeps 21.8% of the pages it cited, Gemini 29.3% and Google AI Mode 42.1%. A chatbot that recommends you today may not tomorrow, which is why one test is never enough.

Each chatbot reads a different web

The chatbots also look in different places. All three cite Slovak websites most of the time, but ChatGPT does so least: a Slovak site appears in 65.6% of its answers, against 81.6% for Gemini and 83.3% for Google AI Mode. What fills the gap is international, English-language sites: Reddit appears in 10.5% of ChatGPT's answers and in under 3% of the others'. Google AI Mode is the one that regularly cites social profiles, Facebook in 10.3% of its answers and Instagram in 6.4%, where ChatGPT almost never does. Gemini cites company websites and little else: hardly any Reddit, LinkedIn or Instagram. LinkedIn is the one place ChatGPT and Google AI Mode both cite often.

CHART 02

Share of each chatbot's answers that cite at least one page from the given place

A site counts once per answer, however many of its pages the answer cites. Slovak websites are all addresses ending in .sk.

citeme.eu, the same answers as chart 01.

So if one chatbot cites you, that says little about the others. And your own website is not the only page that matters: a current Facebook page, a LinkedIn profile or a listing in a Slovak directory can be the page Google's AI reads about you. Where it is worth being listed covers which ones.

An independent study points the same way

Research focused on Google shows the same picture: How Generative AI Disrupts Search (Grossman et al., SIGIR '26) compared Google AI Overviews, regular Google results and Gemini on 11,500 questions asked from the US, collected on 7 and 8 December 2025. The sources the three systems cited overlapped by only 11 to 18%, measured the same way as our chart above.

The study does not include ChatGPT and its questions are not Slovak, so its numbers are not directly comparable with ours. The direction is the same: each of these systems picks its own pages.

Being on page one of Google isn't enough

Google AI Overviews, the AI summary above the regular results, picks its own sources too. In Ahrefs' March 2026 study of 863,000 searches, only 38% of the pages cited in AI Overviews also ranked in the top ten for the same search; BrightEdge puts the overlap at around 17%. A study of 55,000 US searches from spring 2026 found that 30% of the sites cited by AI Overviews appeared nowhere on the first page at all. The exact share depends on how you count, the direction does not: the AI summary and the ten blue links are two different lists.

Our own Slovak searches show the same picture. In 294 Google searches for Slovak search queries, only 27.7% of the pages the AI Overview cited were among the ten regular results of the same search, and in 56% of searches the two lists had at least one page in common.

CHART 03

Of the pages Google's AI Overview cites in our Slovak searches, how many are also among the ten regular results of the same search

27.7%
of the pages the AI Overview cites are among the ten regular results. Roughly one in four.

The search provider does not guarantee a Slovak location, but both lists come from the same search, so the comparison holds.

citeme.eu, 294 Google searches for Slovak search queries, September 4, 2026 – November 14, 2026.
A first-page ranking does not put you into Google's AI answer. Search visibility and AI visibility are two measurements, and they move independently.

What to do

  1. Check more than one chatbot: ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini each read a different set of pages. If you don't want to do it by hand, citeme.eu plans cover all of them.
  2. Test repeatedly. One answer is a snapshot. A share of answers over several weeks is a result.
  3. Look at which pages get cited when you are mentioned, and which when a competitor is. That is where to publish or update. How to improve your AI search visibility walks through the checks.
  4. Then be present in more than one place. Keep your Google Business Profile, Facebook and LinkedIn current and get listed in Slovak directories. For Google's AI answers these pages count as much as your website. Profiles and reviews in citeme.eu also shows the Reddit threads and LinkedIn posts AI already cites in your field, where you can join the conversation yourself.

citeme.eu does this for you: it asks ChatGPT, Google (AI Mode, Gemini, AI Overviews) and other AI chatbots your customers' questions on a schedule, shows how often you are mentioned and which pages each chatbot cites.

How we measured

Every stored answer carries the list of pages the chatbot cited. We cleaned up the addresses (no protocol, no www, no trailing slash) and compared whole pages, not just domains. When comparing two chatbots, we took every question and every day on which both of them answered it, counted how many cited pages the two answers had in common out of all the pages either of them cited, and averaged the result over all those question-days across the whole period; for ChatGPT and Google AI Mode that is 3,274 comparisons. When comparing a chatbot with itself, we put each question's answers in time order and compared each answer with the next one, again averaged over all of them. For AI Overviews we compared the pages the summary cited with the ten regular results of the same search, leaving out searches where Google returned only redirect links. Perplexity answers are in our data but not in this article.

What this result doesn't say

We measured which pages chatbots cite, not how often they name a particular company; that is what AI visibility in citeme.eu tracks for your brand. The data comes from Slovak questions for the brands we track; a handful of brands account for a large share of the answers, so the exact percentages will differ in your field. Which sites AI cites depends strongly on the category, as Where it is worth being for AI to find you shows for law firms, e-shops, accommodation and others. Answers change from run to run; the direction has held across the whole period.

Frequently asked questions

Why does ChatGPT recommend my company but Google doesn't?

Because they read different pages. In our data ChatGPT and Google AI Mode share only 3.5% of the pages they cite for the same question. ChatGPT reaches for international sites such as Reddit more often than Google's chatbots do, and Google's AI answers lean more on Slovak websites, Facebook and Instagram. If the pages Google reads don't mention you, Google's answer won't either, however well ChatGPT knows you. The reverse holds too.

Is being on page one of Google enough to appear in AI Overviews?

Not on its own. Independent studies from 2026 find that only between a fifth and two fifths of the pages AI Overviews cite rank in the top ten for the same search; in our Slovak searches it was 27.7%. The AI summary picks its own sources, so a page-one ranking and a mention in the AI answer are two separate goals.

Is Gemini the same as Google AI Mode?

No. Both come from Google and they are the most alike pair in our data, but even they share only 11.2% of cited pages for the same question. Gemini cites mostly company websites; AI Mode cites social profiles and Slovak sites more often. Check both.

Share

[ MORE ARTICLES ]

[ → ]SEE YOUR OWN DATA

How visible are you?

Find out what AI models say about your brand — and which language they look for the answer in.